| Player |
Years at Millersville |
Drafted |
Organization |
Years |
| Jim Weaver |
1954-58 |
FA |
California Angels (MLB); Cleveland Indians (AAA); Houston Astros (AAA) |
1958-1970 |
| Jim Todd |
1966-69 |
10th Round (232nd) |
Chicago Cubs (MLB); Oakland A's (MLB), Seattle Mariners (MLB) |
1969-1980 |
| Glenn Stitzel |
1964-68 |
27th Round (598th) |
New York Mets (AAA); San Francisco Giants (AA); Philadelphia Phillies (AAA) |
1968-1975 |
| Philip Rossi |
1973-77 |
36th Round (758th) |
Chicago Cubs (A) |
1977-78 |
| Fred Yoder |
1983 |
FA |
Pittsburgh Pirates (A) |
1983 |
| Matt Knox |
1998-01 |
13th Round (397th) |
Cleveland Indians (A+); Lancaster Barnstormers (Atlantic League) |
2001-2006 |
| Matt Scheuing |
1999-03 |
FA |
Bangor Lumberjacks (Northeast League); Lancaster Barnstormers (Atlantic League); Road Warriors (Atlantic League); Atlantic City (Can-Am Association) |
2003-07 |
| Jon Shehan |
2000-04 |
FA |
Atlanta Braves (A) |
2004-05 |
| Derek Kline |
2007-11 |
34th Round (1020th) |
Detroit Tigers (Did not sign) |
- |
| Tim Mayza |
2010-13 |
12th Round (355th) |
Toronto Blue Jays (MLB), New York Yankees (MLB), Pittsburgh Pirates (MLB) |
2013- |
| Mike August |
2010-12 |
FA |
Washington Wild Things (Frontier League) |
2013 |
| Evan King |
2011-13 |
FA |
Southern Illinois Miners (Frontier League) |
2014 |
| Mike Perez |
2010-12 |
FA |
Grand Prairie Airhogs (American Association) |
2014 |
| Tad Barton |
2010-14 |
FA |
Windy City Thunderbolts (Frontier League) |
2014 |
| Chris Murphy |
2013-15 |
24th Round (709th) |
Houston Astros ( A+); Trois-Rivieres Aigles (Can-Am) |
2015-19 |
| Brandon Miller |
2014-16 |
6th Round (177th) |
Seattle Mariners (A), Miami Marlins (A) |
2016-18 |
| Reid Anderson |
2014-16 |
17th Round (519th) |
Texas Rangers (AA) |
2016-19 |
| Tyler Orris |
2013-16 |
33rd Round (980th) |
Colorado Rockies (A-) |
2016 |
| Jim McDade |
2013-16 |
FA |
San Diego Padres (A) |
2016-17 |
| Chas McCormick |
2014-17 |
21st Round (631st) |
Houston Astros (MLB) |
2017- |
| Tyler Yankosky |
2017-19 |
19th Round (573rd) |
Washington Nationals (A+) |
2019-23 |
| Eli Nabholz |
2017-19 |
38th Round (1153rd) |
Milwaukee Brewers (Rk) |
2019 |
| Daniel Ross |
2018-19 |
39 Round (1174th) |
Pittsburgh Pirates (Rk) |
2019 |
| Eric Callahan |
2017-21 |
FA |
Lake Erie Crushers (Frontier League); Idaho Falls (Pioneer League); Empire State (Frontier League) |
2021-23 |
| Thomas Caufield |
2022-23 |
FA |
Washington Wild Things (Frontier League) |
2023- |
| Zack Tukis |
2021-24 |
FA |
Philadelphia Phillies (A) |
2024- |
| Sam Morris |
2022-25 |
FA |
Florence Y'alls (Frontier League) |
2025 |
| Connor Blantz |
2025 |
FA |
Washington Wild Things (Frontier League) |
2025 |
| Amani Jones |
2024-25 |
FA |
Staten Island FerryHawks (Atlantic League) |
2025 |
